Front page of Frank Leslie’s Illustrated Newspaper with wood-engraved portraits of Eliza and Lizzie Scott above, and of Dred Scott and his wife, Harriet, below.

Dred Scott

c. 1799 – 1858

Sued for his freedom; the Supreme Court’s 1857 ruling against him denied Black Americans citizenship.

Draft for committee review

Taken onto free soil

Dred Scott was born into slavery in Southampton County, Virginia, around 1799. He was held by the family of Peter Blow, who brought him to St. Louis in 1830. Blow died there in 1832.

Around 1833 Scott was sold to Dr. John Emerson, a surgeon in the U.S. Army. Emerson took him to Fort Armstrong at Rock Island, Illinois, a free state. In 1836 Emerson moved to Fort Snelling, in a territory where the Missouri Compromise of 1820 barred slavery. Scott went with him.

At Fort Snelling Scott married Harriet Robinson, a teenager enslaved by Major Lawrence Taliaferro. Emerson bought Harriet. In 1838 their daughter Eliza was born aboard the steamboat Gipsey, north of the line the Missouri Compromise had closed to slavery. A second daughter, Lizzie, was born later in Missouri; records disagree on the year.

In May 1840 the army ordered Emerson to Florida. He left his wife and the Scotts in St. Louis, where the Scotts were hired out to others.

Eleven years in court

Emerson died in Davenport, Iowa, in December 1843, and his widow, Irene Emerson, claimed the Scott family. The Scotts were hired out to work in St. Louis. By March 1846 they were hired to a man named Samuel Russell.

On April 6, 1846, Dred and Harriet Scott filed separate petitions for freedom in the St. Louis Circuit Court. “Dred Scott, a man of color, respectfully states to your honor, that he is claimed as a slave by one Irene Emerson,” his petition began. It set out the years he had spent at Rock Island and Fort Snelling, where slavery was barred. Dred Scott signed it with his mark.

The first trial, in June 1847, failed on a technicality in the testimony, and the judge granted a new trial. At the second trial, on January 12, 1850, a St. Louis jury found the Scotts free. Irene Emerson appealed. On March 22, 1852, the Missouri Supreme Court reversed the verdict by a vote of two to one. “Times now are not as they were, when the former decisions on this subject were made,” the court said.

On November 2, 1853, Scott brought a new suit for trespass in the U.S. Circuit Court in St. Louis. The defendant was John F. A. Sanford, Irene Emerson’s brother; the case records spell his name Sandford. In May 1854 a federal jury found that the Scotts were still enslaved.

They had for more than a century before been regarded as beings of an inferior order, and altogether unfit to associate with the white race, either in social or political relations; and so far inferior, that they had no rights which the white man was bound to respect…

Chief Justice Roger B. Taney, opinion of the Court in Dred Scott v. Sandford, March 6, 1857. These are the words of the ruling against Scott; few of his own words survive.

The decision

The U.S. Supreme Court heard the case in February 1856 and again that December. On March 6, 1857, Chief Justice Roger B. Taney read the opinion of the Court. Seven of the nine justices ruled against Scott.

Taney held that Black Americans were not citizens of the United States and could not sue in its courts. He also held that Congress had no power to ban slavery in the territories, and that the Missouri Compromise was unconstitutional. The case went back to the lower court with orders to dismiss it.

The ruling sharpened the national conflict over slavery. The National Archives judges that it moved the country closer to civil war.

Freedom, and after

The Court left the Scotts enslaved. After the ruling, ownership of the family passed to Taylor Blow of St. Louis, whose family had first brought Dred Scott to the city. On May 26, 1857, Blow formally freed the Scott family in a St. Louis court.

Soon afterward a reporter for Frank Leslie’s Illustrated Newspaper visited the family. On June 27 its front page carried engraved portraits of all four Scotts, made from photographs by John H. Fitzgibbon of St. Louis.

Dred Scott lived as a free man for about sixteen months. He died of tuberculosis in St. Louis on September 17, 1858, and was buried in the city’s Wesleyan Cemetery. In 1867 Taylor Blow had his remains moved to Calvary Cemetery. Harriet Scott died on June 17, 1876, at the home of their daughter Lizzie and her husband, Wilson Madison. Their descendants still live in St. Louis.

After the Civil War, the Thirteenth and Fourteenth Amendments overturned the decision that bears his name.

In the archive

Portraits

  • Front page of Frank Leslie’s Illustrated Newspaper with wood-engraved portraits of Eliza and Lizzie Scott above, and of Dred Scott and his wife, Harriet, below. (view at the source, opens in a new tab)
    June 27, 1857The front page of Frank Leslie’s Illustrated Newspaper, with Dred Scott, his wife Harriet, and their daughters Eliza and Lizzie, a month after the family was freed.Wood engravings after photographs by John H. Fitzgibbon of St. Louis. Frank Leslie’s Illustrated Newspaper. The New York Public Library.

Key moments

Dred Scott’s life in time

  1. c. 1799

    Born into slavery in Southampton County, Virginia.

  2. 1830

    Brought to St. Louis by Peter Blow.

  3. c. 1833

    Sold to Dr. John Emerson, an army surgeon, and taken to Illinois.

  4. 1836

    Taken to Fort Snelling, in territory closed to slavery. Marries Harriet Robinson there in 1836 or 1837.

  5. 1838

    Daughter Eliza is born aboard a steamboat in free territory.

  6. 1846

    April 6: Dred and Harriet Scott petition for freedom in St. Louis.

  7. 1850

    January 12: a St. Louis jury declares the Scotts free.

  8. 1852

    The Missouri Supreme Court reverses the verdict.

  9. 1854

    A federal jury finds the Scotts still enslaved.

  10. 1857

    March 6: the U.S. Supreme Court rules against him. May 26: he and his family are freed.

  11. 1858

    Dies September 17 in St. Louis.

June 19, 1865

Connection to Juneteenth

Dred Scott died in September 1858, almost seven years before Union troops reached Galveston, Texas. On June 19, 1865, they announced General Order No. 3, which made known in Texas the freedom proclaimed two and a half years earlier. Scott lived to see none of it. But his case posed the question that Juneteenth, and the years after it, began to answer.

In 1857 the Supreme Court told Black Americans that they could not be citizens and that the nation’s courts were closed to them. After eleven years of lawsuits, the Court left Scott enslaved. His freedom, when it came that May, was not a right the law recognized but a private act by Taylor Blow, whose family had first brought him to St. Louis. Freedom that depended on the will of one man could be given or withheld. Juneteenth marks the moment the nation began to replace such freedom, held at another’s pleasure, with freedom held by law.

Missouri’s own path shows how unevenly that law arrived. Missouri was a slave state that stayed in the Union, and the Emancipation Proclamation did not reach its slaveholders. A state convention abolished slavery there by ordinance on January 11, 1865, five months before Galveston. In Missouri as in Texas, freedom came by a separate act, on its own date, to people who had waited for it.

Harriet Robinson Scott, who had filed her own petition for freedom in 1846, lived on in St. Louis as a free woman, working for years as a laundress. She lived to see the Thirteenth Amendment end slavery in 1865, and the Fourteenth, ratified in 1868, declare, “All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens” of the nation and of their states. Together, says the National Archives, the two amendments overturned the decision that bears her husband’s name. She died in St. Louis on June 17, 1876, eleven years after Galveston.

In 2012 a bronze statue of Dred and Harriet Scott was dedicated on the east side of the Old Courthouse in St. Louis, where their fight began. It honors their struggle for their family’s freedom. Like Juneteenth, it asks those who come after to remember not only the day freedom arrived, but the people who demanded it before the nation was ready to answer.

Sources

Where this story comes from

Every fact on this page is drawn from the sources listed here. Quotations are given as they were first recorded.

  1. Dred Scott (opens in a new tab)National Park Service
  2. Dred Scott Chronology (opens in a new tab)National Park Service, Gateway Arch National Park
  3. Dred Scott Petition Transcript (1846) (opens in a new tab)National Park Service, Gateway Arch National Park
  4. Missouri’s Dred Scott Case, 1846–1857 (opens in a new tab)Missouri State Archives
  5. Dred Scott (opens in a new tab)State Historical Society of Missouri, Historic Missourians
  6. Dred Scott v. Sandford (1857) (opens in a new tab)National Archives, Milestone Documents
  7. Dred Scott v. Sandford (opens in a new tab)National Archives at Kansas City
  8. Dred Scott v. Sandford: Primary Documents in American History (opens in a new tab)Library of Congress
  9. Report of the decision of the Supreme Court of the United States… in the case of Dred Scott versus John F. A. Sandford (1857) (opens in a new tab)Library of Congress
  10. The Dred Scott Decision (American Originals) (opens in a new tab)National Archives
  11. 14th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution: Civil Rights (1868) (opens in a new tab)National Archives, Milestone Documents
  12. Harriet Robinson Scott (opens in a new tab)National Park Service
  13. Harriet Robinson Scott (opens in a new tab)State Historical Society of Missouri, Historic Missourians
  14. Missouri’s African American History Timeline, 1863–1865 (opens in a new tab)Missouri Secretary of State, Missouri State Archives
  15. Dred and Harriet Scott Statue (opens in a new tab)National Park Service, Gateway Arch National Park
  16. Dred and Harriet Scott (Harry Weber, 2012) (opens in a new tab)Regional Arts Commission of St. Louis
  17. Juneteenth: General Order No. 3 (opens in a new tab)National Archives
  18. Eliza and Lizzie, children of Dred Scott; Dred Scott and his wife, Harriet (1857) (opens in a new tab)The New York Public Library

Portraits: Wood engravings after photographs by John H, June 27, 1857. Public domain in the United States.